Ohio Democrats State Logo

Erie County

Democratic Party

Main Navigation

Menu

MENUMENU
  • HOME
  • WHO WE ARE
    • Erie County Democratic Party
      • Erie County Democratic Party Officers – 2022-2026
        • Amy F. Grubbe, Chairwoman
        • James L. Murray, Vice-Chairman
        • Timothy J. Dunlap, Secretary
        • MaryAnn Groot, Treasurer
      • Central Committee Members – 2022-2026
      • Executive Committee Members – 2022-2026
        • Responsibilities of Central and Executive Committee Members
      • ECDP Constitution and Bylaws
    • Democratic Women of Erie County
      • Ohio Democratic Women’s Caucus (ODWC)
    • Erie County Democratic Party Friends
    • Democratic National Committee (DNC)
    • Ohio Democratic Party (ODP)
    • History * Fun Facts * Trivia
      • History: The Democratic Party
      • Ohio History & Trivia
      • How bills become laws in Ohio
      • Kids Fun Facts, Guides & Links to the U.S. Government
    • OPPORTUNITIES TO MAKE CHANGE!
  • ELECTED OFFICIALS
    • President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris
    • U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown
    • U.S. Representative Marcy Kaptur – Ohio’s 9th Congressional District
    • State Senate – Democratic Minority Leadership – 134th General Assembly
    • State House – Democratic Minority Leadership – 134th General Assembly
    • Erie County Democratic Officeholders
      • Erie County Prosecuting Attorney Kevin J. Baxter
      • Erie County Engineer John ‘Jack’ D. Farschman, P.E., P.S.
      • Erie County Recorder Barbara A. Sessler
      • Erie County Sheriff Paul A. Sigsworth
      • Erie County Clerk of Courts Luvada S. Wilson
    • Ohio Supreme Court Justices
      • Ohio Supreme Court Justice Michael P. Donnelly
      • Ohio Supreme Court Justice Melody J. Stewart
      • Ohio Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Brunner
    • Ohio Sixth District Court of Appeals Judges
      • Judge Mark L. Pietrykowski
      • Judge Thomas J. Osowik
      • Judge Myron C. Duhart
    • Erie County Common Pleas Court
      • Judge Tygh M. Tone – General Division
      • Judge Beverly K. McGookey – General Division/Probate
    • Municipal Court Judges
      • Judge Erich J. O’Brien
      • Judge W. Zack Dolyk
    • Margaret M. Murray – ODP State Central Committee Woman – 2nd Senate District
    • Chris Redfern – ODP State Central Committee Man – 2nd Senate District
  • CANDIDATES
    • IMPORTANT: Ohio Redistricting = Erie County new lines and districts
    • Interested in becoming a candidate?
      • What is involved? What are the requirements to be a candidate?
      • Main Street Initiative: Run For Office 2022
    • Congressman Tim Ryan – U.S. Senate
    • Marcy Kaptur – Ohio’s 9th Congressional District
    • Anthony Eliopoulos – Ohio Senate-District 13
    • Bryan Burgess – Ohio House-District 54
    • Jim Obergefell – Ohio House-District 89
    • Nan Whaley – Ohio Governor; Cheryl Stephens - Ohio Lt. Governor
    • Jeffrey A. Crossman – Ohio Attorney General
    • Taylor Sappington – Ohio Auditor
    • Chelsea Clark – Ohio Secretary of State
    • Scott Schertzer – Ohio Treasurer
    • Justice Jennifer Brunner – Chief Justice Ohio Supreme Court
    • Judge Terri Jamison – Associate Justice Ohio Supreme Court
    • Judge Marilyn Zayas – Associate Justice Ohio Supreme Court
    • Tom Puffenberger – Sixth District Court of Appeals
    • Judge Tygh M. Tone – Erie County Common Pleas Court-General Division
    • ODP State Committee Members
      • Margaret M. Murray – ODP State Central Committee Woman-2nd Senate District
      • Tom Galloway – ODP State Central Committee Man-2nd Senate District
  • NEWS
  • ISSUES
    • The American Rescue Plan Act of 2021
    • The American Jobs Plan
    • The American Families Plan
    • Redistricting Ohio
    • SFC Heath Robinson PACT Act
    • Know the petition process!
      • Know your ballot issues!
      • Ohio Ballot Board Members
    • Affordable Care Act
    • Ohio Legislature: Workers’ and Unions’ Issues
    • U.S. Supreme Court
      • Test your knowledge!
      • History of SCOTUS
  • ACTION ITEMS
  • EVENTS
    • Are you ready to vote in 2022?
    • Jim Obergefell – Fundraiser – Wednesday, 8.17.2022
    • ECDP Executive Committee
    • ECDP HQ
    • Democratic Women of Erie County
    • The Sandusky Democratic Club
    • Election 2022: General Election Debates
    • Training: LEAD Ohio 2022 Campaign Staff Academy
    • Voter Registration Drives
    • Erie County Parades, Festivals and Fair
  • LINKS
  • CONTACT US

As SCOTUS agrees to hear Moore v. Harper, why it is potentially dangerous

July 6, 2022

Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to consider Moore v. Harper during their next term in the fall. Even though the majority of the Ohio Supreme Court decided not to hold the Ohio Redistricting Commission republican members’ feet to the fire on two requests for contempt charges, the Ohio Supreme Court has rejected all the maps submitted by the republican majority on the commission as invalid, illegal and unconstitutional. This case would allow the state legislature to draw maps that would be illegal and not subject to state court review.

Marc Elias is an American attorney best known for his involvement in Democratic Party political campaigns, redistricting litigation and election litigation. He has provided more insight into why Moore v. Harper is potentially dangerous. According to Elias, this is “a case that could shake the foundations of federalism and judicial review”.

Moore v. Harper is a North Carolina redistricting case that could shake the foundations of federalism and judicial review and undermine the tools available to protect future elections. On its face, Moore v. Harper looks like a straightforward redistricting case. However. what makes this case so potentially dangerous is the fact that republicans are advancing their radical legal theory – called the independent state legislature (ISL) theory – that would limit state courts’ ability to interpret their own state’s laws and apply their state’s constitutions to federal elections.

In 2011, the North Carolina Legislature drew a new congressional map that illegally used race to limit the influence of minority voters in congressional elections. After a federal court struck that map down, the Legislature drew an avowed partisan gerrymander to achieve the same result. When that map was challenged, a divided U.S. Supreme Court held in Rucho v. Common Cause that federal law and the U.S constitution did not provide standards for invalidating partisan gerrymanders. Thus, the map survived federal court review.

Critically, the Court assured voters that this decision would not “condemn complaints about districting to echo into a void.” Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for the conservative majority in 2019, pointed future plaintiffs specifically to state courts to have their concerns addressed: “Provisions in state statutes and state constitutions can provide standards and guidance for state courts to apply.”

In 2021, North Carolina Republicans again redistricted its congressional maps and again engaged in egregious partisan gerrymandering. This time, taking its cue from the Supreme Court’s ruling in Rucho, plaintiffs sued in North Carolina state court. After significant briefing, expert analysis and testimony, the North Carolina Supreme Court ruled that the map enacted by the Legislature violated the state constitution’s “free and fair elections” clause. The Republican-controlled Legislature then refused to remedy its violation of the state constitution. Instead, its leadership sought Supreme Court review of the decision.

What makes Moore so potentially dangerous is the fact that Republicans are advancing  their radical legal theory — the independent state legislature (ISL) theory — that would limit state courts’ ability to interpret their own state’s laws and apply their state’s constitutions to federal elections. The theory rests on the fact that the U.S. Constitution grants state legislatures the ability to set the “time, place and manner” of congressional elections, subject to an override by Congress. A similar provision gives state legislatures the power to set the “manner” of choosing presidential electors.

In Moore, North Carolina Republicans are arguing that power given to the “legislature” is exclusive to the legislature. In its strongest form, it would exclude a governor’s ability to veto an election bill. In the case of North Carolina, Republicans are arguing that it excludes meaningful judicial review by a state court interpreting its own constitution.

Until recently, the ISL theory was not taken seriously. After all, a bedrock principle of federalism — a tenet of modern conservative legal theory — is that state courts are the ultimate authority on interpreting and applying their state’s laws and constitutions. In addition, stripping or limiting judicial review runs counter to the Supreme Court’s own jurisprudence since Marbury v. Madison.

The concern over ISL is not simply a debate among election lawyers. Adoption of this radical theory would transform the power of legislatures to restrict voting rights and weaken democracy. There is no legal theory that is more connected to Trumpism and the failed Jan. 6 coup than ISL.

In the run up to the November 2020 presidential election, state courts heard and considered dozens of cases involving the application of state election law. As importantly, after the election, Trump and his allies lost 28 lawsuits in state court, nine of which involved the Trump campaign itself. In 2021, at least 39 voting rights and redistricting lawsuits were decided at the state court level.

State courts in Pennsylvania, North Carolina, New Hampshire, Michigan and Montana have played a vital role in protecting the right to vote in free and fair elections. Stripping these courts of the authority to serve as a judicial check on hyper-partisan legislatures will embolden those legislatures to trample on the rights of their citizens and undermine elections. This is what Trump failed to achieve in 2020. An extreme form of the ISL theory is what John Eastman advanced in advising states to disregard the election results. It is not hyperbole to say that the Supreme Court’s decision in Moore may decide whether Eastman, or someone like him, succeeds next time.

Judge J. Michael Luttig was nominated by former President George H. W. Bush to fill the then newly created seat as United States Circuit Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit in Richmond, Virginia. Judge Luttig is a measured conservative not known for overstatement who recently wrote that “Trump and the Republicans can only be stopped from stealing the 2024 election at this point if the Supreme Court rejects the independent state legislature doctrine.” He is correct. It is that simple. The U.S. Supreme Court will either empower the likes of Eastman and Trump or it will stand behind the dozens of state court judges who protected our elections in those 28 cases. These are the stakes when SCOTUS considers Moore v. Harper next term. A dangerous theory will have its day in court.

Blog Sidebar

Categories

  • News
  • Uncategorized

Recent Posts

  • As SCOTUS agrees to hear Moore v. Harper, why it is potentially dangerous
  • Redistricting continues with some good news
  • Ohioans will have second Primary August 2 with unconstitutional maps
  • Deja Vu: Rejected Third Plan becomes Fifth Plan as Ohio Supreme Court contemplates contempt charges
  • Ohio’s redistricting chaos continues as GOP drags feet

Archives

  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • November 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2019

Trending

Initiatives

Recent News

  • As SCOTUS agrees to hear Moore v. Harper, why it is potentially dangerous
  • Ohioans will have second Primary August 2 with unconstitutional maps
  • Deja Vu: Rejected Third Plan becomes Fifth Plan as Ohio Supreme Court contemplates contempt charges
  • Ohio’s redistricting chaos continues as GOP drags feet
  • Ohio Supreme Court rejects 4th set of Ohio House and Senate maps
  • Ohio’s redistricting continues to get messier
  • Ohio redistricting chaos becomes even more chaotic and complicated
  •  
  • View all news

Current Issues

  •  
  • View all issues

Pages

MENUMENU
  • HOME
  • WHO WE ARE
    • Erie County Democratic Party
      • Erie County Democratic Party Officers – 2022-2026
        • Amy F. Grubbe, Chairwoman
        • James L. Murray, Vice-Chairman
        • Timothy J. Dunlap, Secretary
        • MaryAnn Groot, Treasurer
      • Central Committee Members – 2022-2026
      • Executive Committee Members – 2022-2026
        • Responsibilities of Central and Executive Committee Members
      • ECDP Constitution and Bylaws
    • Democratic Women of Erie County
      • Ohio Democratic Women’s Caucus (ODWC)
    • Erie County Democratic Party Friends
    • Democratic National Committee (DNC)
    • Ohio Democratic Party (ODP)
    • History * Fun Facts * Trivia
      • History: The Democratic Party
      • Ohio History & Trivia
      • How bills become laws in Ohio
      • Kids Fun Facts, Guides & Links to the U.S. Government
    • OPPORTUNITIES TO MAKE CHANGE!
  • ELECTED OFFICIALS
    • President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris
    • U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown
    • U.S. Representative Marcy Kaptur – Ohio’s 9th Congressional District
    • State Senate – Democratic Minority Leadership – 134th General Assembly
    • State House – Democratic Minority Leadership – 134th General Assembly
    • Erie County Democratic Officeholders
      • Erie County Prosecuting Attorney Kevin J. Baxter
      • Erie County Engineer John ‘Jack’ D. Farschman, P.E., P.S.
      • Erie County Recorder Barbara A. Sessler
      • Erie County Sheriff Paul A. Sigsworth
      • Erie County Clerk of Courts Luvada S. Wilson
    • Ohio Supreme Court Justices
      • Ohio Supreme Court Justice Michael P. Donnelly
      • Ohio Supreme Court Justice Melody J. Stewart
      • Ohio Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Brunner
    • Ohio Sixth District Court of Appeals Judges
      • Judge Mark L. Pietrykowski
      • Judge Thomas J. Osowik
      • Judge Myron C. Duhart
    • Erie County Common Pleas Court
      • Judge Tygh M. Tone – General Division
      • Judge Beverly K. McGookey – General Division/Probate
    • Municipal Court Judges
      • Judge Erich J. O’Brien
      • Judge W. Zack Dolyk
    • Margaret M. Murray – ODP State Central Committee Woman – 2nd Senate District
    • Chris Redfern – ODP State Central Committee Man – 2nd Senate District
  • CANDIDATES
    • IMPORTANT: Ohio Redistricting = Erie County new lines and districts
    • Interested in becoming a candidate?
      • What is involved? What are the requirements to be a candidate?
      • Main Street Initiative: Run For Office 2022
    • Congressman Tim Ryan – U.S. Senate
    • Marcy Kaptur – Ohio’s 9th Congressional District
    • Anthony Eliopoulos – Ohio Senate-District 13
    • Bryan Burgess – Ohio House-District 54
    • Jim Obergefell – Ohio House-District 89
    • Nan Whaley – Ohio Governor; Cheryl Stephens - Ohio Lt. Governor
    • Jeffrey A. Crossman – Ohio Attorney General
    • Taylor Sappington – Ohio Auditor
    • Chelsea Clark – Ohio Secretary of State
    • Scott Schertzer – Ohio Treasurer
    • Justice Jennifer Brunner – Chief Justice Ohio Supreme Court
    • Judge Terri Jamison – Associate Justice Ohio Supreme Court
    • Judge Marilyn Zayas – Associate Justice Ohio Supreme Court
    • Tom Puffenberger – Sixth District Court of Appeals
    • Judge Tygh M. Tone – Erie County Common Pleas Court-General Division
    • ODP State Committee Members
      • Margaret M. Murray – ODP State Central Committee Woman-2nd Senate District
      • Tom Galloway – ODP State Central Committee Man-2nd Senate District
  • NEWS
  • ISSUES
    • The American Rescue Plan Act of 2021
    • The American Jobs Plan
    • The American Families Plan
    • Redistricting Ohio
    • SFC Heath Robinson PACT Act
    • Know the petition process!
      • Know your ballot issues!
      • Ohio Ballot Board Members
    • Affordable Care Act
    • Ohio Legislature: Workers’ and Unions’ Issues
    • U.S. Supreme Court
      • Test your knowledge!
      • History of SCOTUS
  • ACTION ITEMS
  • EVENTS
    • Are you ready to vote in 2022?
    • Jim Obergefell – Fundraiser – Wednesday, 8.17.2022
    • ECDP Executive Committee
    • ECDP HQ
    • Democratic Women of Erie County
    • The Sandusky Democratic Club
    • Election 2022: General Election Debates
    • Training: LEAD Ohio 2022 Campaign Staff Academy
    • Voter Registration Drives
    • Erie County Parades, Festivals and Fair
  • LINKS
  • CONTACT US
Donate Now

© 2022 Erie County Democratic Party, All Rights Reserved

Paid for and authorized by the Erie County Democratic Party, Amy F. Grubbe, Chairman

P.O. Box 135, Sandusky, OH 44871-0135.

Not authorized by any Federal, state or county candidate or campaign committee.